Robert Desprez Communications

  • My Services
  • My Blog
  • About Me
  • Contact Me
You are here: Home / Robert Desprez | Vancouver technical writer | Blog / Do We Rely Too Much on Technology?

Do We Rely Too Much on Technology?

June 18, 2015 by RDesprez Leave a Comment

Tweet

Does soft­ware automa­tion improve or ham­per your life?

Most peo­ple embrace the idea of tech­nol­o­gy. How many peo­ple real­ly would rel­ish writ­ing a let­ter or even an email with­out spell check? Or endure a rush-hour dri­ve into a for­eign city with­out a GPS system?

Nicholas Carr, author of The Glass Cage, argues that for all of technology’s ben­e­fits, it has its share of per­ils. When peo­ple use com­put­ers, they often fall vic­tim to a pair of cog­ni­tive ailments—automation com­pla­cen­cy and automa­tion bias.

Technology Can Harm our Careers and Threaten Lives

Automa­tion com­pla­cen­cy lulls us into a false sense of secu­ri­ty. Carr writes: “We become so con­fi­dent that the machine will work flaw­less­ly, han­dling any chal­lenge that may arise, that we allow our atten­tion to drift. We dis­en­gage from our work, or at least the part of it that the soft­ware is han­dling, and as a result may miss sig­nals that some­thing is amiss.” Any­one who uses a word proces­sor will have expe­ri­enced this: per­haps the spell check doesn’t catch an embar­rass­ing error. Or a foot­er does not dis­play the cor­rect information.

Automa­tion bias occurs when peo­ple give too much cre­dence to the infor­ma­tion dis­played by a com­put­er. Even when the infor­ma­tion is wrong or mis­lead­ing, peo­ple may still believe it. One alarm­ing exam­ple is a dri­ver of a school bus who mis­tak­en­ly rammed into a con­crete bridge in Seat­tle, injur­ing 21 stu­dents. The dri­ver told police that he had been fol­low­ing the GPS instruc­tions and “did not see” signs and flash­ing lights warn­ing of the impend­ing bridge.

Soft­ware automa­tion is every­where in our soci­ety. Accoun­tants use deci­sion-sup­port soft­ware in cor­po­rate audits. The soft­ware expe­dites the work but “there are trou­bling signs that as the soft­ware becomes more capa­ble the accoun­tants become less so,” writes Carr. One study, con­duct­ed by a group of Aus­tralian pro­fes­sors, exam­ined the effect of the soft­ware sys­tems used by three account­ing firms. Those accoun­tants who had to make more of the deci­sions them­selves had “a sig­nif­i­cant­ly stronger under­stand­ing of dif­fer­ent forms of risk” than the oth­er accoun­tants who relied on the soft­ware. “The decline in learn­ing asso­ci­at­ed with advanced soft­ware affect­ed even vet­er­an audi­tors,” writes Carr.

A ten­den­cy to be increas­ing­ly reliant on soft­ware is not unique to accoun­tants. Finan­cial pro­fes­sion­als, lawyers, doc­tors, human resource pro­fes­sion­als, pilots all rely on soft­ware to com­plete aspects of their jobs. The book con­tains many exam­ples of how these well-edu­cat­ed pro­fes­sion­als become over­ly reliant on tech­nol­o­gy and make mistakes—sometimes life-threat­en­ing ones.

Online Information May Weaken our Memory

In the devel­oped world, most of can­not imag­ine our lives with­out an Inter­net con­nec­tion and a search engine.

When you type in a search query using Google, the search engine does a great job of fig­ur­ing out what you want. It cor­rects your spelling. It sug­gests search terms. It even antic­i­pates your needs based on who you are and the terms you have used in the past. Over time, you might think that users are learn­ing from Google’s sug­ges­tions so that they are more savvy when typ­ing search terms.

The oppo­site is true. A series of exper­i­ments in Sci­ence mag­a­zine show that all the avail­able online infor­ma­tion weak­ens our mem­o­ry for facts. Why remem­ber fac­tu­al con­tent when a search engine will do it for you? The researchers con­clud­ed: “Since search engines are con­tin­u­al­ly avail­able to us, we may often be in a state of not feel­ing we need to encode the infor­ma­tion internally.”

Amit Sing­hal, Google’s lead engi­neer, notes that the bet­ter Google’s search engine becomes, the lazier we are with our typ­ing and queries.

Most of us wouldn’t accept a world with­out soft­ware, whether it’s a GPS, bank­ing soft­ware, or a smart­phone. Tech­nol­o­gy has rev­o­lu­tion­ized our lives in many pos­i­tive ways. But for those of us enam­oured with tech­nol­o­gy, Carr’s book is a a cau­tion­ary tale—don’t let your guard down too much when using it.

Filed Under: Robert Desprez | Vancouver technical writer | Blog, Technology Tagged With: automation, Search engines, technology

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Robert Desprez

I have worked as a Vancouver technical writer for more than 20 years, working at some of British Columbia's largest high-tech firms. I have served in leadership positions for the Society for Technical Communication and have worked as a writing instructor at Vancouver's Simon Fraser University.

Robert Desprez Follow 1,153 240

Vancouver Technical Writer. Former Instructor at Simon Fraser University. Dog Lover. Coffee Drinker. Tennis and Piano Player.

robert_desprez
robert_desprez avatar; Robert Desprez @robert_desprez ·
13 Jun 1933531572986409204

Image for twitter card

Canada’s love affair with EVs has stalled, putting Ottawa’s mandate in doubt

Sales have tumbled after pauses in consumer subsidies from Quebec and Ottawa

www.theglobeandmail.com

Reply on Twitter 1933531572986409204 Retweet on Twitter 1933531572986409204 0 Like on Twitter 1933531572986409204 1 Twitter 1933531572986409204
robert_desprez avatar; Robert Desprez @robert_desprez ·
9 Jun 1931884220026384734

Image for twitter card

Is AI dulling critical-thinking skills? As tech companies court students, educators weigh the risks

Artificial intelligence is the latest technology stoking fears of human decline. Early studies stoke doubt about whether the fear is warranted

www.theglobeandmail.com

Reply on Twitter 1931884220026384734 Retweet on Twitter 1931884220026384734 0 Like on Twitter 1931884220026384734 0 Twitter 1931884220026384734
robert_desprez avatar; Robert Desprez @robert_desprez ·
8 Jun 1931841743097651237

Image for twitter card

Want to read more books? There’s an app for that – with a catch

It would be great to get smarter in just 15 minutes a day. But bite-sized books have their limitations

www.theglobeandmail.com

Reply on Twitter 1931841743097651237 Retweet on Twitter 1931841743097651237 0 Like on Twitter 1931841743097651237 0 Twitter 1931841743097651237
robert_desprez avatar; Robert Desprez @robert_desprez ·
7 Jun 1931387924311912959

Companies must make changes for training to be effective for younger workers /via @globeandmail

Companies must make changes for training to be effective for younger workers

Bottom line: for training to be effective today, especially for younger employees, it needs to be customized, relevant and timely

www.theglobeandmail.com

Reply on Twitter 1931387924311912959 Retweet on Twitter 1931387924311912959 0 Like on Twitter 1931387924311912959 0 Twitter 1931387924311912959
Load More

Recent Blog Posts

  • ChatGPT: The AI-Powered Proofreader
  • Four Ways Confluence Could Be Better
  • First impressions of MadCap’s purchase of IXIASOFT
  • Online Conferences for Technical Writers in 2023

About Me

Robert Desprez I have worked as a Vancouver technical writer for more than 20 years, working at Kodak, Boeing, Teck Resources, and FortisBC. In addition, I have worked as a writing instructor at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver.

Contact Me

Robert Desprez Com­mu­ni­ca­tions Inc.
North Van­cou­ver, British Columbia
Canada
Phone: 604–836-4290

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2025  · Robert Desprez Communications Inc.

Lightbox image placeholder

Previous Slide

Next Slide

Share

Facebook ShareTwitter ShareLinkedin SharePinterest ShareEmail Share

TwitterTwitter
Hide Tweet (admin)

Add this ID to the plugin's Hide Specific Tweets setting: